Skip to main content

Peer Review reports

From: Pedicled medial femoral condyle corticoperiosteal flap for achieving union in patients with nonunion of the distal half of the femur (A short case series of three patients)

Original Submission
13 Dec 2023 Submitted Original manuscript
Resubmission - Version 2
Submitted Manuscript version 2
13 Jan 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report - Matteo Guzzini
13 Mar 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
11 Apr 2024 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 3
11 Apr 2024 Submitted Manuscript version 3
16 Dec 2024 Reviewed Reviewer Report
3 Jan 2025 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 4
3 Jan 2025 Submitted Manuscript version 4
3 Jan 2025 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 5
3 Jan 2025 Submitted Manuscript version 5
3 Jan 2025 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 6
3 Jan 2025 Submitted Manuscript version 6
4 Jan 2025 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 7
4 Jan 2025 Submitted Manuscript version 7
21 Mar 2025 Author responded Author comments - Nader Kamiel Salieb
Resubmission - Version 8
21 Mar 2025 Submitted Manuscript version 8
Publishing
10 Apr 2025 Editorially accepted
15 May 2025 Article published 10.1186/s12891-025-08644-6

You can find further information about peer review here.

Back to article page